Forum Thread

Shinichi I think Sylveon may have chose the Wizard because maybe she didn't know that Four was a wizard. Still though I have my doubts about that theory. I have never been a hunter in this game before ( I played werewolf somewhere else but Hunter had some role ), so I don't know the judgement behind a Hunter's choice so who knows. I still think she wasted her kill.

---

Why would Four be a hunter?

I meant Wizard sorry

---

( random question, when will votation start? )

---

Hunter's power only triggers when they are killed, they either use it or lose it. Even if executed, she can take someone down with her.

So, either the Serial Killer stabbed her in the back or the Werewolves attacked her, but since it was only 2 deaths, must have been the latter.

Trick is, Hunter has to choose who to shoot, she can't see in the dark, so she fires in the direction she thinks her attacker was.

Think of how terrible it would have been had she shot one of the lovers. Which may have been why she picked an identified role, so not to hit one of them.

----------------------------------------
Okay, we need to be more careful, here is what we know and the current status of everyone:

SylveonGirl23 - Deceased - Hunter
KevinXDE - Alive - Former Cupid? Twice?
razorblade620 - Alive - Milkman?
Lapis~~Lazuli - Deceased - Saboteur
Lunar_Dragonsong - Alive - ????
Tsukishima - Deceased - Werewolf
Shinichi - Alive - Baker?
Tx_Son_of_Liberty - Alive - ????
Guzma - Alive - Mayor/????
meme - Deceased - Villager
TurquoiseMuffins - Alive - ????
Mikage - Alive - Villager?
Four - Deceased - Wizard
BellaFox - Alive - ????
Pilufa - Beyond - Narrator

Roles still not claimed: Thief, Fortune Teller/aka Villain's #1 Target, Serial Killer, Werewolves... but that is still very smart by all of them.

Tx, I don't think picking an identified role would have avoid the possibility of hitting the lovers. And, to be honest, I'd try to kill the lovers. I know who they are, and they still haven't claimed any roles. They both could be werewolves, or no one of them. Or maybe 1 of them. We don't know cause they didn't say anything regarding this

So, I'll vote for one of them. That's my opinion. We could get rid of a werewolf quite faster.

---

Do you want to start voting now?

---

I don't know if anyone else will say something? I'd wait for a bit

Just in case, I'm going to reveal the lovers. BellaFox and Tx_Son_of_Liberty

Why don't you two claim a role?

---

Well, you knew my opinion on revealing the lovers (Thanks, painting a target on my back), especially with a Serial Killer, all it does is help the Werewolves. Also, if the werewolves were the Lovers, they'd have revealed first day, it would only work to protect themselves longer. One would claim villager, other would claim Thief or Fortune Teller, then tell you they saw their lover as Villager or stole villager.

One piece of good news Pilufa revealed... we only have 2 Werewolves left, which means the Thief didn't become a 4th Werewolf. That is awesome!

We have five people who have not claimed roles, plus 1 "Villager", yet there are only 4 unclaimed non- plain Villager roles, claiming Vanilla Villager is the ultimate cover, it is why I hate having them in One-Night Werewolf Games, even Baker and Milkman are great covers for Werewolves, as all they do is protect one another. We have to be very careful on this Vote.

If you're right, we kill the lovers, and they're both werewolves, we still don'the win the game (Serial Killer can kill all of us), if you're totally wrong we kill 2 villagers and the Werewolves and Serial Killer can kill two more people tonight, meaning tomorrow the wolves and Serial Killer will outnumber the good villagers and would almost guarantee a win for evil. Even if you're sort of right and one wolf is linked to a good villager, that Villager could be the Fortune Teller, the last weapon in the Village Arsenal, and we'd still be sacrificing another villager to get only one werewolf.

We'd actually be better off voting for no one and hoping the Serial Killer and Wolves accidentally kill each other tonight than sacrificing the lovers on the miniscule chance you made the two remaining werewolves the lovers.

If we want to win, we have to find the Serial Killer too, maybe even first, as they win when they're the only villager alive, werewolves have to tie the villager to Werewolf Ratio.

I have no idea what BellaFox is, I was the thief, but the Werewolves would know I wasn't one of them, so revealing that only made me an easy target. Or did you not notice the wolves chose the Hunter, figuring the Hunter had better odds of hitting another villager than themselves.

Revealing your role is rarely good, because the Werewolves already know who ALL the villagers are but they have no way to tell one villager's value from another, and the best way to out the Wolves is to get them to claim a role, especially when the Fortune Teller can confirm that the next night, or connected roles can undermine them or unite to vote against them. Until now, you, BellaFox, and I had a secret voting block, we knew each other and you knew us, and the reveal of your unchallenged former cupidhood was a good play as it let BellaFox and me know who you were without compromising us. Shinichi and razorblade620 are linked and can vote together. But now all of us are out in the open, so the Serial Killer and Werewolves can weaken our unification, use what we know against us, and seed doubt and confusion.

Couldn't the wizard save themselfs? :(
Anyways I can only be on very short now and won't be online for a time, so I can't really discuss anything more :/ (prom)

---

@Lunar
I feel like the Wizard can't save/kill themselves xD That just kinda defeats the purpose (to me at least.)

---

Yes, the Wizard can save himself/herself.

Also, good prom Lunar o/

---

How could you know I was the cupid if I didn't reveal the names of the lovers before? I could still have been lying. And it's unlikely that a Werewolf claims to be something specific, cause the person who has the real role would expose them. If there's a Werewolf, they usually claim to be Villager (or even Thief. See Turquoise last round). Pilufa said 2/3 Werewolves are alive. So, there's still the chance you are not a Villager. Low chance though. Let's see what does Bella say.

Also, the chance of one of you being Werewolf or Serial Killer is higher than being the Villager or Fortune Teller. If you decide who to vote, I'll listen though

---

I don't have any real evidence, but yesterday (in game day), SylveonGirl23 thought TurquoiseMuffins was suspicious, and then last night, it seemed like the Serial Killer didn't kill anyone... but, what if the Werewolves and the Serial Killer all attacked poor SylveonGirl23? Then it would look like the Serial Killer didn't attack anyone, but in actuality she did. Plus... we did get the muffins on the body that first morning, so unless Shinichi just likes throwing breakfast foods on people's bodies, it does seem suspicious.

Also, as a politeness, might I suggest we all (Villagers, Werewolves, Serial Killers, etc.) abstain from harming Lunar_Dragonsong until after she returns and allow her the sanctuary of her prom without the taint of her character potentially dying?

Why do I always disagree with you xD? Can't understand

Why would we allow that? She didn't claim a role as well. Also asking to protect somebody specific is quite suspicious, you know? Why don't protect Turquoise or Guzma? Just because Lunar is going doesn't mean she's a Villager role.

Sorry if I sound rude, it's not my intention.

State who are you going to vote, please :s

---

There are 4 people with roles unclaimed. Let's allow them to claim roles or vote away one of them. TX liberty, turquoise​, Bella, Lunar

Am I allowed to write a final message? It doesn't have ANY HINTS WHATSOEVER

---

ok

---

Did Turquoise or Guzma mention being gone? I've seen both on. Lunar is going to prom, it is mean to ruin a girl's prom by killing her off while she can't even be around to defend herself from us Villagers, and it just seems bad form for the Villains to take advantage of her while she is gone.

How I knew you were Cupid is because you chose me, and then did what I'd previously suggested to you as Cupid to do, which I took as a hint that you were letting me know you were cupid... I was not 100% sure, but it was good enough to go on as baseline to work off of unless someone challenged you, in which case we could ask each of you could reveal one lover, and if either of you got one wrong, it would out you, but no one challenged you, which implied you were the real deal.

I think I'm voting TurquoiseMuffins... she seems suspicious. As I said, I have only hunches and the fact the Serial Killer either didn't kill anyone or also chose to target SylveonGirl23, which would be odd for a Serial Killer to do, unless SylveonGirl23's distrust was already aimed at the Serial Killer (Why SylveonGirl23 chose to shoot poor Four, when he'd claimed to be the Wizard, is beyond me. Sort of left us totally in wolf poo).

Shinichi, I did just claim a role, because KevinXDE pushed. As I said, I was the thief, and flipped both Villagers, so I had no choice in the matter really. As we know, there are only 2/3 Werewolves left, and not 3/4 (which is a good thing, cause more wolves is bad for all of us... well I guess it wouldn't be as bad for me and the other wolves, but that is because I'd be a wolf, but that is besides the point)

Tx, we started with 3/4. Tsukishima died, then now we have 2/3.

---

Oh, you're confusing, I thought you meant 2 out of 3... not 2 or 3. It was unclear. But as the thief, I know it is only 2 of 3, because I'm not the 4th.