Log In
Dragon Weather Castform Don't have an account yet? Register now!
.

Forum Thread

MAFIA!

Forum-Index → Forum Games → MAFIA!
Nishinoya
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 41

Forum Posts: 646
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 10:09 (7 Years ago)
G'morning peeps!

I'm the next overseer as you probably know.
Due to the fact that it is my first time being an overseer, I'm not quite sure how priorities of actions are decided. And because I want it to be a fair round, I'm asking you all - before roles are decided - how you want the priorities set.

1st option: First come, first serve
This means that the actions are going to be counted in the order they're sent. If for example a goon sends me their target before the Doctor, the target will be killed even though the Doctor saved it.
pretty sure not many people want this xD

2nd option: Party priority
Meaning that first, the town roles act, after that, Mafia and then 3rd party. Then the party actions will be decided by first come, first serve.
So for example, when people palpad me their actions in the following order:
Goon, SG, Doctor, Godfather, Vigilante, Serial Killer
The actions will be counted in this order: SG, Doctor, Vigilante, Goon, Godfather, Serial Killer

3rd option: I can't think of a fitting name for this one
It's just a set order, which would be:
Jailkeeper > (Mayor [if roleblocked, their vote counts only once]) > Cop > SG > Doctor > Mafia actions (Facestabber first) > 3rd party actions (Serial Killer first)

4th option: I'm open for other suggestions of priorities
Just tell me if you'd like the priorities set otherwise. ;u;
However, we currently have 18 players:

Seer
StrongFish91
Starflight
America_Ball
Xurkitree
Technology
meme
Shinichi
Bete_Noire_666
Tx_Son_of_Liberty
Derpadoo
Waffle
Tsukishima
TurquoiseMuffins
Lunar_Dragonsong
Suvansh
Pilufa
Lyrreax

I'll give out the roles as soon as the priority setting is decided.

Note: I'm going to be at a friend's house until monday, so I'm not sure if I can keep this up until then as we're spending more time on video games and talking than on the computer oops. However, I will ask her if I can use her computer a few times and post the night start and night results here if I'm allowed.
IF I DON'T POST AFTER 24 HOURS, PLEASE MAKE SOMEONE ELSE TAKE MY PLACE UNTIL MONDAY. THANK YOU. (Though I don't think that this will happen, I wanted to let you know before you all freak out x3)
Entity
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 14

Forum Posts: 0
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 10:47 (7 Years ago)
I'd prefer the 2nd option. The Mafia has an advantage anyways because they know who their fellow Mafia friends are, the Town memers don't. So in order to balance that, the town moves should be counted first.
Nishinoya
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 41

Forum Posts: 646
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 10:53 (7 Years ago)
The 3rd option also features the Town Actions counting first, but the order in which they act is set.
2nd option is pretty much a mix of the 3rd and 1st, considering that Town actions count first but the priority is decided in the order in which they're palpadded.

just though I might say this again in case it wasn't clear
PhoeniXXTalon
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 42

Forum Posts: 465
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 10:54 (7 Years ago)
2nd seems good to me tbh
Pilufa
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 32

Forum Posts: 563
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 11:52 (7 Years ago)
for sure not 1st.

my preferred order would be:

JK, SG, Doctor, Serial Killer, Vigilante, Mafia, Reviver

also, as Mayor is a "Day" role, any Night roleblock shouldn't apply on him. (Only Silencer ofc)
Nishinoya
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 41

Forum Posts: 646
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 11:55 (7 Years ago)
You're probably right about the Mayor, so we might change it
Also I don't think the SK should act before mafia as this would give a kinda unbalanced advantage to the town
Sure, Mafia know their team mates, but they still need to have a fair chance or winning.
Suvichan
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 36

Forum Posts: 570
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 11:56 (7 Years ago)
I have no prob for any role

This awesome art and Avatar is made by Grietine! Visit her deviantart.
Pilufa
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 32

Forum Posts: 563
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 12:08 (7 Years ago)
I guess the SK should have an advantage because he is the only in his party.
Lyney
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 54

Forum Posts: 636
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 12:12 (7 Years ago)
I don't really like the options but if I hat to choose one, I would do 1

”Mysterious… surprising… and law-defying… Isn’t that right?”
Entity
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 14

Forum Posts: 0
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 12:32 (7 Years ago)
The first option would lead to unfairness due to the fact that the Mafia knows their teammates while the Town doesn't. So it is most likely that the Mafia will commit their actions first and then gaining a second advantage over the Town.
Nishinoya
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 41

Forum Posts: 646
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 12:38 (7 Years ago)
Agreed with Lyrreax.

I think option 2 is okay then? I'll send out the roles after I took a shower :v
Pilufa
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 32

Forum Posts: 563
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 13:19 (7 Years ago)
long shower
zuramaru
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 65

Forum Posts: 316
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 13:24 (7 Years ago)
first come first serve is good, just put the roleblock actions and doctor first or something, but only if that's comfortable to you

Pilufa
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 32

Forum Posts: 563
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 13:28 (7 Years ago)
first come first serve is the worst thing ever and makes no sense

it would be impossible to put it into an irl game too
Entity
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 14

Forum Posts: 0
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 13:31 (7 Years ago)
@Nishinoya please remove me from the game list if First come, first serve is getting chosen. Thanks
Pilufa
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 32

Forum Posts: 563
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 13:38 (7 Years ago)
^

Same for me
Nishinoya
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 41

Forum Posts: 646
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 13:39 (7 Years ago)
Yes I do take long showers, don't judge >:v

We'll use the 2nd option. The roles are sent in a few minutes

EDIT

Roles are sent!
If someone didn't receive a role, please PalPad me about it. But I'm pretty sure I didn't do any mistakes ;u;

Day 1 - Start!

List of players:
Seer
StrongFish91
Starflight
America_Ball
Xurkitree
Technology
meme
Shinichi
Bete_Noire_666
Tx_Son_of_Liberty
Derpadoo
Waffle
Tsukishima
TurquoiseMuffins
Lunar_Dragonsong
Suvansh
Pilufa
Lyrreax
Ralsei
ONLINE
Trainerlevel: 59

Forum Posts: 737
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 14:17 (7 Years ago)
Sweet! Let's do this :v
Nishinoya
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 41

Forum Posts: 646
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 14:46 (7 Years ago)
Alright, as I'm heading out now at there's not much to discuss during Day 1, I might as well start the first night.

Night 1 - Start
PalPad me your targets and place your votes if you have any!
Scare_Crow
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 91

Forum Posts: 404
Posted: Sat, 29/04/2017 14:46 (7 Years ago)