Log In
Bug Weather Castform Don't have an account yet? Register now!
.

Forum Thread

Profile Post Function

Forum-Index → Suggestions → Rejected → Profile Post Function
RetroSanityTTV
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 45

Forum Posts: 32
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 18:09 (9 Years ago)
My idea is to be able to write on peoples wall, like a function where they can post anything they want (besides profanity, harsh words etc) sometimes i can not find people on Palpad ( and yes i am friends with them) or when i send them a personal message they sometimes do not see it, the use can also approve of the post and delete as they please, so what i propose is that you get a notification if someone writes on your wall, also the ability to comment on each others post such as Facebook, Twitter etc ;)
CarpetMonster
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 34

Forum Posts: 1,134
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 18:14 (9 Years ago)
You can just use the Pal Pad search function at the bottom to look for their username. I personally wouldn't want people using my profile as a message board, so unless the user whose profile is being used can delete the messages people post on it and/or need to approve everything that gets posted, I would really rather not have this feature.

Edit: Also, this was already suggested. Literally the top thread in the forum when you were posting this. Please make an effort to avoid posting suggestions that have already been made by either using the forum search or just looking at recent threads.
RetroSanityTTV
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 45

Forum Posts: 32
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 18:16 (9 Years ago)
Of course the user of the page can decide whether the post can be there or not and they can also decide if they would like to delete it, like it states anyway, this is only a suggestion, also you not being an admin on this page does not effect me in the slightest, i know peoples opinions are aloud but you negativity is not.
CarpetMonster
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 34

Forum Posts: 1,134
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 18:21 (9 Years ago)
You can't say "of course" the user can decide now. It was absolutely not obvious, because you never said anything of the sort. Please add details to your suggestions instead of leaving them up to everyone's imagination, especially if you're going to act like they were obviously included and it was your plan all along afterwards. Nobody is going to guess what you mean in a suggestion if you don't say it.
Every suggestion is "only a suggestion." That's not a defense against criticism.

Also, in case you didn't see my edit, this was already suggested. It was literally the first thread in the forum when you made this thread. Please don't post duplicate suggestions - use the other thread to post your opinion.

Quotealso you not being an admin on this page does not effect me in the slightest, i know peoples opinions are aloud but you negativity is not.
Can you explain what you mean by this? I have no idea what you just said.
RetroSanityTTV
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 45

Forum Posts: 32
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 18:23 (9 Years ago)
This post is staying none the less unless removed by an admin
CarpetMonster
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 34

Forum Posts: 1,134
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 18:25 (9 Years ago)
Why? It's unnecessary, because, as I have linked twice now, there is a thread with the same idea from before you said this.
Dhoulmagus
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 19

Forum Posts: 10
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 18:39 (9 Years ago)
The premise behind the idea is so you have more control on how to interact with people other than sit and wait for a message back, if you can't understand that and still believe you have a valid point to argue, then you obviously can't think much.
and Just to point out, that is directed to you CarpetMonster, and I know that this may be taken as me bein harsh, but I don't have the time or patience for stupid
CarpetMonster
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 34

Forum Posts: 1,134
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 20:07 (9 Years ago)
Excuse me?! You don't call people STUPID and assert that they CANNOT THINK because they disagree with you and have a perfectly valid reason to do so.
First of all, how do I not have a right to not WANT messages about me publicly posted on my profile?
Second, how is that, as you claim, the premise of the idea when the original poster said in his second post that the user would, "of course," still have to approve all messages on his or her profile?
Third, how does messages being public make any difference in the fact that you have to wait for the user to reply?

The answers:
> I do.
> It's not.
> It doesn't.

(Oh, and for the FOURTH time now, this has already been suggested. ♥)
imagine
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 94

Forum Posts: 2,087
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 20:15 (9 Years ago)
No Support.

I wouldn't want people posting on my profile regardless if the user is my friend or not. This is also a potential SPAM-causer as well as an opportunity for more beggars to attempt to contact you. But also...

Quote from DoncleCoresometimes i can not find people on Palpad ( and yes i am friends with them) or when i send them a personal message they sometimes do not see it

As CarpetMonster said, you can just user the search feature at the bottom of the PalPad.
I also don't see how someone can't see a large "" icon on their userbar.

Quote from DoncleCore[...] also the ability to comment on each others post such as Facebook, Twitter etc

We can already comment on feeds made by users and this is an adoptable browsergame, not Facebook, Twitter, MySpace, or Instagram.

Quote from DhoulmagusThe premise behind the idea is so you have more control on how to interact with people other than sit and wait for a message back

You would already have to "sit and wait for a message back" if the user is offline or away from their computer. Besides, not everyone can sit in front of their computer 24/7 to reply to you right at the instant you want them to. Everything in life takes time so just take the time to wait.
In conclusion, I don't support this suggestion because the idea of other users posting on my userpage is revolting, you can search for a user's username in the PalPad search feature, this is an adoptable browsergame and not a social media website, and all you need is to have a little patience.




Dhoulmagus
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 19

Forum Posts: 10
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 20:50 (9 Years ago)
You prove your intellectual deprivation by still not understanding that by havin something where you can post on a users page isn't a plausible benefit. You just show that you're either ignorant or neglecting of social protocols. If there is no profanity or obscenity being posted then there is only a benefit, as it encourages users to engage with one another more and actually be able to build social bonds with each other whilst enjoying the different things possible on this website other than there being a waiting period as to when and whether or not another user will reply, so yes I will call you stupid, not for an opinion but purely as an obvious intellectual superior
CarpetMonster
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 34

Forum Posts: 1,134
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 20:55 (9 Years ago)
QuoteIf there is no profanity or obscenity being posted
That's a REALLY big if, considering that you're insulting me right now over this very discussion. There's no guarantee that people WON'T do what you're doing right now, so yes, there IS a good chance that people will say bad things.
And besides, I've explained why no good will come of it period (because it's utterly useless), while you're only asserting that "if no bad comes of it, then no bad will come of it" and throwing around insults like confetti. It's easy to see who has the superior argument here.
RetroSanityTTV
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 45

Forum Posts: 32
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 20:56 (9 Years ago)
No one is forcing you to use this option and as a respected member of this community, i will try my best to make the community better, you two and your negativity are not helping and the fact you keep posting shows the you are completely being ignorant to what i am trying to portray and like i said before it is not needed for you to post and considering you guys are not being supportive does not help me, if it gets removed by an admin then i will understand
Besides if more people vote on this being a positive thing, all this talk means nothing, yeah it may have a few tweaks but the fact i am trying to make the community better is by far none of your concern, plus i will hope for a feature where you can turn the feature on and off.
Dhoulmagus
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 19

Forum Posts: 10
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 21:05 (9 Years ago)
The only reason you're being called names is because you're being negative about a good possibility and just throwing all idea of it down the drain, most likely due to your ignorance or neglect of normal social conduct. As it's been said, either carry on replying like an ignoramus or you can just drop it and instead sit down and think about it properly
CarpetMonster
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 34

Forum Posts: 1,134
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 21:13 (9 Years ago)
Actually, we are being forced to have people post on our profiles. We can choose not to post on theirs, but that doesn't stop them from using the feature on us.
And I don't appreciate being called ignorant and negative for disliking a suggestion when someone else is getting away with actually insulting me, calling me stupid and saying I am incapable of thinking and comprehending social standards. How am I the one being "negative" here?
I have explained multiple times why it does not have any actual use and that it can be used to post hurtful messages, a point which you are actually proving RIGHT NOW, and that you can already talk to people in a way that is no less useful and no more difficult to use. Meanwhile, you have ceaselessly insulted me for no reason and not actually explained yourself, and insisted that I don't understand "social standards." Clearly you're the one who doesn't know what is socially acceptable if you think publicly insulting someone is going to get them to "drop it."
And for the record, the staff doesn't just look at the numbers. They read the posts, too. And they consider their own opinions. If all they see is that people are being bullied into supporting the suggestion, it doesn't matter what the numbers say - it's not getting accepted.
RetroSanityTTV
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 45

Forum Posts: 32
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 21:18 (9 Years ago)
Did i insult you? No, i do not think i did, i put this post therefor what i say means more then what you say, i have not been negative to you, let alone insulted you, back up your facts before accusing on what someone else said, then numbers do count as people want the community to be better and as i have said before i will ask for an option where the user can either have it off or on.
CarpetMonster
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 34

Forum Posts: 1,134
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 21:20 (9 Years ago)
You called me "ignorant" and said a feature that affects the community is "none of [my] concern," effectively claiming I'm not a member of the community despite having actively participated in the site since only a week after its creation, solely because I don't agree with you. If that's not an insult, I don't know what is.
RetroSanityTTV
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 45

Forum Posts: 32
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 21:22 (9 Years ago)
Was the claim made by me, can you quote that i exactly said that? No, exactly, your points are invalid and the point you continue to comment just makes you look like an idiot (Just for the record i did not say you are an idiot) and when i asked you politely to stop commenting you carried on so yeah you were bring ignorant
Princess
ONLINE
Trainerlevel: 91

Forum Posts: 388
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 21:23 (9 Years ago)
First off if this has been suggested before it doesn't need a new thread. There is no need for this thread if it has already been suggested.

Secondly Please don't be rude to my friends. They were just giving their opinion. Thanks! :]

Oh and can't you just comment on someones feed?

Dhoulmagus
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 19

Forum Posts: 10
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 21:23 (9 Years ago)
And you continue to prove your negative. You're being insulted because of that, and you aren't even understanding that so how can you get the idea of what is being suggested. If you wasn't to be completely negative, do you think anything would of been said bad about you? So, do you wish to continue an argument in which you will have bad things said to you
imagine
OFFLINE
Trainerlevel: 94

Forum Posts: 2,087
Posted: Wed, 22/07/2015 21:24 (9 Years ago)
Quote from AutumnStarIf you've made a suggestion, remember that everyone is entitled to their opinion, and if someone doesn't agree with your idea or your idea is rejected, don't take it personally. Everyone has PokeHeroes' best interests in mind here.
CarpetMonster and I are voicing our opinion.
You can't make a suggestion and expect everyone to like it.

In my opinion this is a terrible suggestion that would just wreak havoc on the Pokeheroes Community.
Quote from DoncleCoreBesides if more people vote on this being a positive thing, all this talk means nothing, yeah it may have a few tweaks but the fact i am trying to make the community better is by far none of your concern, plus i will hope for a feature where you can turn the feature on and off.
That's not how ... any of this works ...
Quote from RiakoA positive Support/Non-Support ratio does not mean that your suggestion is going to be implemented! It's still up to me/the staff to decide wheter an idea is worth the effort or not. Like I said, there are already hundreds of suggestions - and most of them are really awesome. But: We can't implement them all at once.

So... begging your friends to support an idea in order to get a very positive Support/Non-support ratio is both pathetic and useless :P The final decisions are still up to the staff.
Rather try to develop your idea properly.
I'm lowkey wondering if you even read the Suggestion Guides at all lol.
I also don't see the point of this argument as it's rather petty and annoying.
I feel no one should have gotten butthurt over someone not supporting this suggestion and that instead of publicly calling someone "stupid" and such you should have conversed the whole thing out with them via PM.